Order Now for Pickup in West Haven, CT
Orders are available for pick up on Thursdays and Fridays. If you need your cookies shipped please check our "gift boxes" page!
Accepting Orders
Delivery fee -
Min. order - $15.00
Free delivery above
Pickup
Delivery
Dine-In
Pickup time: Up to 30 minutes
Pickup Address: 80 Prindle Road, West Haven, CT 06516-3913
Evjoy Specialty Cookies
Made with the highest quality ingredients including organic flour and single-source spices.
Specialty Cookie Flavors - Winter 2026
Please note your order must be placed by Tuesday 3pm to be fulfilled in the same week.
Our a la carte menu changes seasonally. For more flavors visit our gift box or subscription pages.
This section is next available for ordering on September 20th at 9:00AM.
Ready to order?
WHAT PEOPLE ARE SAYING!
"Like a holiday in my mouth. So good!"
Matt & Anya Mussenden
What they ordered: Holiday Box 2025
What is a
Specialty Cookie?
.png)
Baked clean, baked local
No preservatives or food additives ever! Just pure, delicious joy.
One of a kind
Discover unique twists on classic favorites, international flavor profiles, and uncommon luxury ingredients. Each menu is thoughtfully curated to maximize joy. And, every recipe is our own.
Artisanal
ingredients
​​​
Crafted with the best of the best: organic flour, organic eggs, CT maple sugar, organic honey, unrefined organic cane sugar, single-source spices, and farm-fresh produce.
Entirely from scratch
Every cookie is a true labor of love. Every topping, filling, and dough is made in-house using our own recipes. No hidden ingredients here.
Our Cookie Services
Cookies for every occasion
