Order Now for Pickup in West Haven, CT
Orders are available for pick up on Thursdays and Fridays. If you need your cookies shipped please check our "gift boxes" page!
Evjoy Specialty Cookies
Made with the highest quality ingredients including organic flour and single-source spices.
Specialty Cookie Flavors
Please note your order must be placed by Tuesday 3pm to be fulfilled in the same week. Our a la carte menu changes seasonally. For more flavors visit our gift box or subscription pages.
*Seasonal* Georgia Peach
Juicy, sweet peaches are stuffed into our maple sugar dough and sprinkled with lime zest for an incredible summer dessert. We source our peaches from The Peach Truck company, ensuring we get the most delicious fruit (that's never sprayed!) straight from Georgia.
$3.75
Belgian Chocolate Chunk
Luxuriously creamy. You’ll taste luscious Belgian 70% dark chocolate, semi-sweet chocolate chips, creamy butter, and organic Madagascar vanilla beans.
$3.75
Triple Chocolate
Dark chocolate cookie stuffed with Belgian milk chocolate ganache and topped with semi-sweet chocolate chips. You'll taste dark, rich cocoa and velvety milk chocolate.
$3.75
Peanut Butter Praline & Jelly
An Evjoy twist on a classic! This cookie is packed with scratch-made peanut butter praline and organic strawberry jam in a brown butter cookie base. You'll taste nuttiness, sweet, salty, and fruity goodness.
$3.75
Cardamom Honey Oat Crumble
Single-Source Cardamom from the Cloud Forest. Local CT Honey. Organic Sprouted Oats. Warm and cozy.
$3.75
Sticky Toffee Pudding
Sweet, decadent, sticky... all the things that make sticky toffee pudding amazing in a portable bite. You'll taste rich date infused toffee and toasted walnuts.
$3.75
Passionfruit Torched Coconut Meringue
Sweet, tart, and fruity. This cookie is stuffed with a passionfruit Belgian white chocolate ganache and topped with torched coconut meringue pieces. You'll taste warm weather, sunshine, toasted coconut, and fruity goodness.
$3.75
Pistachio Strawberry Rose
Nutty, sweet, and a touch floral, these pistachio cookies are stuffed with a scratch-made, gooey strawberry rose jam and topped with Belgian white chocolate.
$3.75
Guava
If you like guava, you'll love these guava-stuffed cookies.
$3.75
Brown Butter Caramel Swirl
Dark chocolate and vanilla cookie doughs are swirled together and stuffed with brown butter caramel. Topped with caramel shards and semi-sweet chocolate chips. Unreal.
$3.75
Ube Matcha Swirl
Earthy and sweet, these Ube and Matcha cookies are stuffed with Ube Belgian white chocolate ganache. You'll taste vanilla, sweet white chocolate, and earthy matcha.
$3.75
Maple Sugar Confetti
Like a sugar cookie, but better. Made with and rolled in CT maple sugar to bring out the maple syrup flavor. Sweet, fun, and delicious!
$3.75
Cookie Platters
Hosting an event? Looking for a special treat for your office? Shop our cookie platters.
Small Cookie Platter
One dozen (12) cookies, in our best-selling flavors. Choose up to 3 cookie flavors!
$43.00
Large Cookie Platter
Three dozen (36) cookies in our best-selling flavors. Choose up to 3 cookie flavors!
$120.00
Mini Cookie Platter
Three dozen (36) of our mini cookies in our best-selling flavors. Choose up to 3 cookie flavors!
$80.00
Orange Farmer's Market
Made with the highest quality ingredients: single-source, fair trade spices, organic unbleached flour, award-winning butter, and, often, local organic produce. Zero additives or unhealthy chemicals.
Dessert Specials
Creative and seasonal.
S'mores Mini Tart
Valhorna dark chocolate cookie crust, Belgian milk chocolate ganache, scratch made toasted marshmallow fluff. *We use organic agave instead of corn syrup for the marshmallow fluff.
$7.00
WHAT PEOPLE ARE SAYING!
"Like a holiday in my mouth. So good!"
Matt & Anya Mussenden
What they ordered: Holiday Box 2025
What is a
Specialty Cookie?
.png)
Baked clean, baked local
No preservatives or food additives ever! Just pure, delicious joy.
One of a kind
Discover unique twists on classic favorites, international flavor profiles, and uncommon luxury ingredients. Each menu is thoughtfully curated to maximize joy. And, every recipe is our own.
Artisanal
ingredients
​​​
Crafted with the best of the best: organic flour, organic eggs, CT maple sugar, organic honey, unrefined organic cane sugar, single-source spices, and farm-fresh produce.
Entirely from scratch
Every cookie is a true labor of love. Every topping, filling, and dough is made in-house using our own recipes. No hidden ingredients here.